CONTACT US

Send us a message

* Please fill in the form below.
In Depth: Sailing Through North

In Depth: Sailing Through North

The Suez Canal is still the most efficient route to transport large amounts of cargo between Asia and Europe.

 

However, due to the melting of sea ice in Arctic regions, ships are able to sail faster from East Asia to Western Europe by taking the Northeast Passage. Furthermore, the development of a railway connecting China with Europe enables another way for goods to be transported faster between East and West.

 

Can these quicker trading routes cause a shift in the transport of cargo among Asia and Europe? And what kind of opportunities can these alternative ways of transportation bring to the Dutch maritime sector?

 

Over the past decades climate change has led to higher temperatures in the Northern Arctic. As a result, the amount of sea ice has decreased significantly, making the Arctic waters above Russia better navigable. Maritime companies, especially shipping companies, have an interest in the development of a Northeast Passage as it shortens the trade route between East Asia and Western Europe.

 

When compared to the conventional Suez Canal route, the Northeast Passage has the potential to greatly diminishes the sailing distance. For example, ships departing from Shanghai, Yokohama or Busan to the destination Rotterdam are able to decrease their journey by 2,511 to 4,122 nautical miles, which is about 25-37 per cent.

 

Significant increase Before the year 2008, the Northeast Passage was rarely used as a maritime route between Europe and Asia. Shipment of dry cargo in the Arctic waters above Russia was mainly domestic.

 

However, between 2008 and 2016, the amount of ships using the Northeast Passage for international shipping significantly increased. From only a few vessels a year in the early 2000s to an annual average of 41 vessels between the period 2011-2016.

 

Though this is a significant increase, it is just a fraction in comparison to the approximate 17,000 vessels that annually pass the Suez Canal. Therefore, there have to be other factors besides shipping distance that play a role for shipping companies to choose a trade route.

 

The Arctic route actually brings a series of challenges that undermines the economies of scale achieved by large containerships. First of all, the coastal route of the Northeast Passage has shallow bathymetry. The Sannikov and Dmitry Laptev Straits have depths of about 13 and 7 metres, which limits the maximum cargo size per ship to approximately 2500-4500 TEU.

 

Second, the Suez Canal offers greater predictability to shipping companies since it is navigable whole year-round. Vessels which use the Suez Canal do not have to depend on the season and on the assistance of ice breakers.

 

Third, the limited amount of ports for maintenance and support and the absence of highly populated coastal areas are a disadvantage of the Northeast Passage. Container ships rarely unload all cargo at a single destination, but visit several large ports on their voyage to distribute cargo.

 

COSCO breaks the ice

 

On September 10, 2013 the Chinese vessel Yong Sheng arrived in the Port of Rotterdam and became the first container ship to complete a voyage through the Arctic. By using the Northeast Passage, the journey of the Yong Sheng from Shanghai to Rotterdam was approximately 9 days and 2,800 nautical miles shorter in comparison to the traditional Suez Canal route. As a result, China Ocean Shipping (Group) Company, also known as COSCO, is taking the lead among shipping companies to use the Northeast Passage as a new cargo route for Euro-Asia trade.

 

In a press release article, COSCO advocates that the Northeast Passage brings numerous advantages to shipping companies. First, shipping companies can cut costs by choosing the Arctic route instead of the shipping through the Suez Canal.

 

“Enormous expenditures on fuel, canal transit, and security can be saved.”

 

Also shipping companies can promote energy conservation as the Northeast Passage reduces fuel use and emission by about 35 percent. While COSCO sent five vessels through the Arctic Ocean in 2016, it is yet a fraction of COSCO’s fleet which consists of approximately 700 modern merchant vessels.

 

Economic lure Michiel Nijdam, corporate strategist at Port of Rotterdam, views the Northeast Passage as a niche market for shipping.

 

“Because of its shallow depths, the Arctic Ocean is economically not interesting for container shipping. However, the Northeast Passage does bring new possibilities for the transport of natural resources. Bulk carriers and tankers are able to easier transport minerals, metals and oil from Northern Russia to China, Japan, Scandinavia, and even the Netherlands.”

 

Nevertheless, Nijdam does not expect the Northeast Passage to create a significant increase of shipping activity to the port of Rotterdam.

 

While the potential of the Northeast Passage to compete with the Suez Canal as a major trading route between Asia and Europe is limited, the Arctic Ocean does offer various other business opportunities.

 

“The Arctic waters create opportunities for Dutch companies in the fields of offshore, ship building and port construction. Take for instance BigRoll, an innovative provider of heavy marine transportation solutions located in Leiden. They have successfully delivered four deck carriers to the Yamal LNG (Liquefied Natural Gas) Project, which is located in the middle of the Northern Arctic Route. BigRoll constructed these carriers specifically to operate in the Arctic Waters, and are therefore equipped with Finnish Swedish 1A Ice Class,” Nijdam said.

 

New Silk Road

 

In 2013 the Chinese government announced its policy of ‘One Belt, One Road,’ an initiative of China to enhance international trade by improving its transportation network. As most trade routes were based on China’s historical silk road network, this program was quickly dubbed the ´New Silk Road.’

 

One of these routes, an overland connection between China and Europe, was however never realized before. Nevertheless, the Chinese government invested heavily in the development of a railway system and within a few years the first trains started running.

 

Nowadays there are about 2 to 3 trains a week operating from Chengdu – Tilburg – Rotterdam. With a transit time of approximately 14-17 days, the New Silk Way offers a quicker transportation route than by sea, which takes 5-6 weeks. The increase of cargo transport between Asia and Europe by train is the result of manufacturers and transport companies to explore new opportunities.

 

Within China, ‘the factory of the world’, many manufacturers are shifting their production from coastal areas to inland regions to save costs on labor and land. As a result, the New Silk Road is becoming more accessible to Chinese makers.

 

On the other hand, European companies are also jumping on the bandwagon. Royal Wagenborg, as one of the founders of New Silk Way Logistics, took an active role in connecting the Netherlands to the rail line between Germany and China.

 

According to Paul Bakker, Manager Business Development at Royal Wagenborg, the New Silk Road is interesting for return cargo from the West to the East.

 

“At the moment there is a large trade imbalance between China and Europe. Full containers from China arrive daily in Europe, but filling these containers with return cargo still remains a challenge. Since these containers eventually have to return to China, shipment prices are limited. Taking the cost and transit time of cargo into account, rail transport can be more cost efficient than air freight and sea freight.”

 

The New Silk Road is thus a beneficial alternative for companies which wish to ship their products between Europe and Asia within a few weeks, but are not willing to pay the expensive air freight charge.

 

Royal Wagenborg sees also other business possibilities in the New Silk Road besides export. Short sea shipping is mentioned as an example by Bakker.

 

“Products arriving from Europe in China by train can be shipped further to Japan or South-Korea. Otherwise, cargo arriving in Rotterdam, the end station of the New Silk Road, can be additionally transported to areas which are not connected to the train network. Options are Great Britain, Scandinavia, and even the East Coast of the United States, as container shipment by sea directly from China takes even more time.”

 

Perspective

 

At the moment trains on the New Silk Road transport about 85,000 TEU of cargo annually. Based on the current train lines, Port of Rotterdam estimates that within a few years cargo transport on the New Silk Road can grow to a maximum of 400,000 TEU. In contrast, about 45,000,000 TEU of cargo, largely from Asia, arrives annually in the harbors of Europe.

 

For the time being, Nijdam does not expect a big shift in the transport of cargo between Asia and Europe.

 

“Shipment by sea is still a lot more economical than by train. A large container vessel can take up to 18,000 to 22,000 TEU, while a train on the New Silk Road carries about 50 TEU per ride.”

 

On the other hand, the New Silk Road can bring different opportunities which cannot be realized by either the Suez Canal or the Northeast Passage trade routes. Bakker sees the train network as an efficient instrument to approach new markets.

 

“Eastern Europe, Kazakhstan and the West of China are now easier accessible for Dutch companies.” And as the New Silk Road keeps on developing, Royal Wagenborg expects the amount of train rides to increase and new destinations to be added to the railway network. “Besides a rail connection between Rotterdam and Chengu, the New Silk Way also connects other European hubs, such as Hamburg and Duisburg, with various Chinese provinces.”

 

All in all, neither the Northeast Passage nor the New Silk Road currently have to potential to replace the Suez Canal as the largest trade route between Europe and Asia. Yet both trading routes are developing rapidly and offer diverse maritime business opportunities. The Northeast Passage enables a shorter seasonal trade route and offers maritime transportation of resources in Russia’s northern waters. While the New Silk Road brings more possibilities for short sea shipping in Western Europe as well as East Asia.

 

Marnix Viergever

 

This article was previously published in Maritime Holland edition #6 – 2017.

Subscribe to our mailing list

* indicates required

OTHER NEWS

  • Khalifa Port Set to Handle Capesize Ships under EGA Deal
  • CMA CGM Completes Acquisition of Brazilian Cabotage Carrier Mercosul Line
  • World’s Biggest Automated Box Terminal Starts Trial Operation
  • China's 'Smart' Ship Debuts in Shanghai
  • Panama Canal Increases Daily Number of Neopanamax Vessel Slots as Efficiency Improves
  • Breaking: EU Okays COSCO’s OOCL Takeover
  • MSC Hires MacGregor to Upgrade 31 of Its Ships
  • Dutch Consortium to Study Autonomous Shipping
  • Maersk Line Closes Hamburg Süd Acquisition
  • In Depth: Sailing Through North
  • German Court Rejects Appeal Against Elbe River Dredging
  • Loaded Container Shipments to Break 200 Mn TEU Mark
  • Rotterdam Wants to Become Zero-Emissions Port by 2050
  • Hapag-Lloyd Adds Low Carbon Refrigerant Containers from Maersk
  • Alphaliner: Global Container Volumes Grow by 7.7 percent in Third Quarter
  • Cyber Liability Hampers Unmanned Ship Implementation
  • Hapag-Lloyd Eyes Market Share Grab on Asia-South America Container Trades
  • Singapore Wants to Start Using Aerial Drones for Remote Ship Inspections
  • Singapore Suspends Trade Relations with North Korea
  • SeaIntel: ​Low Vessel Utilization Puts Pressure on Freight Rates
  • Maersk: Shipping Must Raise Its Game to Cut Pollution
  • Oversupply causing fall in container shipping rates
  • Yang Ming Swings Back to Profit
  • Pakistani Shipbreaking Plot Sealed Off
  • CMA CGM Becomes World’s First Company To Use LNG For 22,000 TEU Ships
  • Maersk Steers Shipping Forecasts Lower
  • Cosco Shipping Ports to Build Freight Station at Khalifa Port
  • WWEA and IWSA Will Jointly Promote Wind Technology in Shipping
  • British Containership Loses 42 Containers Overboard Off Japan
  • Oil Traders Set Sights on High Seas as Diesel Renaissance Is Born
  • One carrier in particular has absorbed Hanjin's vessels
  • MSC orders 11 new 22,000-TEU vessels
  • Maersk Line: Digitalization Is a Must If You Want to Survive
  • McKinsey Says Container Shipping Should Digitize
  • UNCTAD: Consolidation in Container Shipping May Lead to Oligopoly
  • Qatari Vessels Have Banned from Suez Canal Ports
  • APL Launches New Korea China Straits Service
  • Hamburg Port Becomes Main ULCV Stop With New Cranes
  • World’s First Floating Wind Farm Opens Up Off Scotland
  • Rotterdam’s Box Volumes Continue Growing
  • Panama Canal Ends FY17 with Record Annual Cargo Tonnage
  • 2020 Sulphur Cap: Maersk Is Not on the Scrubber Team
  • Gloomy outlook for liner shipping as container rates continue to slide
  • Russia Setting Up Direct Shipping Line to Syria
  • Storm Wreaks Havoc in Port of Durban - Container Ship Blocked Port
  • CMA CGM: Indian Sub-continent Service Enhancement
  • Container rates still on the slide as Asia-Europe peak season 'fizzles out'
  • CMA CGM to increase its South Pacific footprint with acquisition of Sofrana Unilines
  • Are Chinese Banks New Source of Capital for Shipping?
  • Panama Canal Authority to Allow Booking Slot Swaps Among Alliance Members
  • Euroseas, Poseidon Eye Merger of Container Fleets
  • Norway Sets Up Second Test Area for Unmanned Ships
  • Hapag-Lloyd fleet 'now complete' as latest UASC newbuild ULCV is delivered
  • The SCFI recorded a fall of 4.6 percent for Asia- North Europe spot rates.
  • SeaIntel: Cascading of Larger Ships Hurting Asia-ECSA Rates
  • MSC Turns to DSME for 22,000 TEU Megaships
  • Latest ULCV orders the start of a slippery slope to new overcapacity glut?
  • SeaIntel: Q2 Results Paint a Better Picture for Container Carriers
  • Shipping in Changing Climates
  • Second hand Containership Sales at Record Level
  • More rate slippage on east-west trades as carriers prepare for slack season
  • Maersk credit rating downgrade threats are a red herring, argues financial analyst
  • SASAC Gives Green Light to COSCO-OOCL Deal
  • Carriers prepare for the slack season by blanking Asia-Europe sailings
  • Cntracking was at the 86th Izmir International Fair
  • Milaha has announced the launch of the first direct reefer service between Qatar and Turkey.
  • OOCL celebrates arrival of sister to the world's biggest containership
  • Drewry: Asia-Southern Africa Rates at 7-Year High
  • We hereby sincerely invite you to visit our booth at 86th Izmir International Fair
  • Merdan Erdoğan appointed CEO of www.cntracking.com
  • Hong Kong secures its shipping hub status with nod to vessel-sharing agreements
  • EU trade agreement creates healthy tailwind for Japan's ONE group
  • CMA CGM ULCV order could send ripples across tradelanes as rates strengthen
  • Top Carriers More Reliable in Q2
  • CMA CGM will launch new service linking Black Sea to Morocco and Algeria
  • MOL Delivers Stronger Quarter, Raises Outlook
  • Container spot rates on the rise, from Asia to the US, and Asia to Europe
  • Cosco acquisition of OOCL still faces “a degree of uncertainty”
  • ULCVs to Almost Double Capacity Share on Asia-North Europe by 2018
  • Soft Asia-Europe spot rates will harden as peak season approaches
  • Maersk still feeling effects of cyber attack
  • The negotiations for trade arrangements between the US and China have been concluded
  • CMA CGM, SEATRADE Enter Vessel Sharing Deal
  • More bigger ships set to put more pressure on Asia-Mediterranean container trade
  • Diana Containerships Ties Boxship Duo with Maersk, CMA CGM
  • WSC: Number of Containers Lost at Sea Drops
  • Cosco buys OOCL for USD 6.3 billion
  • Japan’s Trio Sets Up Container Shipping JV
  • Yildirim to Sell CMA CGM Stake as Plans to Buy Ports America
  • Hapag-Lloyd Ups Volume of Euro Bond Offering
  • Japanese carrier trio miss first target for ONE merger, but it's all 'going to plan'
  • CMA CGM sells 90 pct stake in L.A. container terminal for $817 mln
  • Maersk Claims Victory Over Cyber Attack
  • Cyber attack victims Maersk and TNT find ways to keep customers' cargo moving
  • Maersk Cyber Attack: Will Ocean Freight Rates Increase ?
  • Maersk suffers a cyber attack causing IT systems to fail
  • Wan Hai Boosts China-Vietnam-Thailand Links
  • South Africa rejects Japanese container line merger proposal
  • ZIM must plot a course through some choppy financial waters
  • Fitch: Boxship Rates Rise, Capacity Still Key
  • Transpacific rates still under pressure but Asia-Europe space still tight
  • MSC prepares contingency plan for cargo aboard Rickmers charters
  • Imabari Launches 20,150 TEU MOL Boxship
  • Maersk Line Not Accepting Cargo to/from Qatari Ports
  • Hapag-Lloyd becomes latest carrier to bring in container booking cancellation fee
  • Middle East air freight disruption looms as Qatar is blacklisted over 'terror links'
  • Japanese liner shipping trio becomes ONE, ready for launch next spring
  • FMC Discusses Regulatory Reform Initiative and Ocean Carrier Alliances
  • China-Europe rail boom as forwarders latch on to cost advantage for customers
  • Hapag-Lloyd finally completes merger with UASC
  • APL turnaround brings significant boost to CMA CGM first-quarter results
  • Uber Freight officially parks in the marketplace, but only taking full loads
  • China Sparks World Container Traffic Boom
  • Navios Containers Eyes USD 75 Mn for Rickmers Fleet
  • Shippers squeezing margins 'pushed carriers toward bigger ships and alliances'
  • Crane Falls at Jebel Ali Port after Boxship Collision, No Fatalities
  • Nerves jangle as shippers and forwarders wait to hear who is bankrolling Yang Ming
  • Future Management of Hamburg Süd Unveiled
  • Shock for Japanese shipping lines as merger plan is rejected by US FMC
  • Yang Ming Expects 2nd Stage of Recapitalization by June
  • targets 3% growth as next-generation Triple-Es start to arrive
  • Sharp Decline in Idling Boxships
  • APL Enhances China-Indonesia Coverage
  • Yang Ming Halts Share Trading
  • Shanghai port, world's busiest, grapples with traffic congestion
  • Drewry: Bigger Ships to Continue Pressuring Freight Rates
  • Alibaba extends partnership with KN to cover cross-border B2B shipments
  • Seago Line Sees Modest Profit amid Lower Freight Rates
  • ZIM, MSC Upgrade North Europe Express Service
  • DHL Says Ocean Freight Rates Have Reached Turning Point
  • CMA CGM Strengthening EURAF 5 Services
  • OCEAN Alliance Starts Ploughing the Seas
  • Yang Ming losses continue to mount after 2016 revenue slump
  • FMC green light for 2M Alliance co-operation with HMM on transpacific
  • NYK, K Line and MOL pass first marker buoy en route to the merger