CONTACT US

Send us a message

* Please fill in the form below.
Hong Kong secures its shipping hub status with nod to vessel-sharing agreements

Hong Kong secures its shipping hub status with nod to vessel-sharing agreements

The Hong Kong Competition Commission has issued a five-year block exemption order for liner shipping vessel-sharing agreements (VSAs). However, it declined to issue a similar exemption for vessel-discussion agreements (VDAs). The order, announced on Tuesday, follows two years of legal uncertainty for shipping lines after the city’s Competition Ordinance came into effect in 2015.

 

At the time, interpretation of Hong Kong’s new antitrust regulations was uncertain and there was speculation on whether VSAs, which form the basis of container shipping alliances, would become effectively illegal.

 

In that case, without an exemption, carriers could face heavy fines – up to 10% of their Hong Kong turnover for up to three years. Furthermore, with such exemptions already in place at competing transhipment hubs in Singapore, Malaysia and mainland China, carriers warned they could have to abandon Hong Kong calls.

 

The commission’s decision acknowledged the “economic efficiencies generated” by VSAs and followed an application by the Hong Kong Liner Shipping Association (HKLSA) in December 2015. The commission said VSAs, which carriers use to manage capacity via slot exchange and joint service agreements and alliances, were “unlikely to result in significant harm to competition, unless the VSA activities allow members to enjoy some degree of market power”.

 

It exempted VSAs from the Ordinance’s ‘First Conduct Rule’ so long as parties to a VSA do not collectively exceed a market share limit of 40% and the VSA does not “authorise or require shipping lines to engage in cartel conduct”. VDAs, where carriers share commercial information like rates, were not exempted, on the basis that “it was not demonstrated that the relevant VDA activities meet the terms of efficiency exclusion”.

 

According to legal firm Ince & Co, carriers are required to use guidance published by the commission to self-assess which VDA activities would cause competition concerns. It said parties involved “need to assess the nature of the VDAs carefully to ascertain whether the nature and content of discussions fall within what could be considered acceptable by the competition commission”. The decision to exclude VDAs was welcomed by Hong Kong Shippers’ Council executive director Sunny Ho. He said: “VDAs, entirely anti-competitive in nature, remain a core of any competition considerations.”

 

However, HKLSA secretary general Roberto Giannetta told The Loadstar he was disappointed that VDAs were excluded. “We are pleased that the HKCC recognised the value and numerous efficiencies of carrier cooperative agreements and has granted an exemption for operational agreements. On the flip side, we are disappointed that the HKCC did not grant the same level of value and efficiency by extending the exemption to commercial agreements (VDAs).

 

“Many neighbouring jurisdictions have very recently reviewed their own exemption applications for shipping and have reconfirmed that these VDAs promote valuable efficiencies for carriers, customers, local consumers and national economies.”

 

 

 

 

 

Source: The Loadstar

OTHER NEWS

  • Merdan Erdoğan appointed CEO of www.cntracking.com
  • Hong Kong secures its shipping hub status with nod to vessel-sharing agreements
  • EU trade agreement creates healthy tailwind for Japan's ONE group
  • CMA CGM ULCV order could send ripples across tradelanes as rates strengthen
  • Top Carriers More Reliable in Q2
  • CMA CGM will launch new service linking Black Sea to Morocco and Algeria
  • MOL Delivers Stronger Quarter, Raises Outlook
  • Container spot rates on the rise, from Asia to the US, and Asia to Europe
  • Cosco acquisition of OOCL still faces “a degree of uncertainty”
  • ULCVs to Almost Double Capacity Share on Asia-North Europe by 2018
  • Soft Asia-Europe spot rates will harden as peak season approaches
  • Maersk still feeling effects of cyber attack
  • The negotiations for trade arrangements between the US and China have been concluded
  • CMA CGM, SEATRADE Enter Vessel Sharing Deal
  • More bigger ships set to put more pressure on Asia-Mediterranean container trade
  • Diana Containerships Ties Boxship Duo with Maersk, CMA CGM
  • WSC: Number of Containers Lost at Sea Drops
  • Cosco buys OOCL for USD 6.3 billion
  • Japan’s Trio Sets Up Container Shipping JV
  • Yildirim to Sell CMA CGM Stake as Plans to Buy Ports America
  • Hapag-Lloyd Ups Volume of Euro Bond Offering
  • Japanese carrier trio miss first target for ONE merger, but it's all 'going to plan'
  • CMA CGM sells 90 pct stake in L.A. container terminal for $817 mln
  • Maersk Claims Victory Over Cyber Attack
  • Cyber attack victims Maersk and TNT find ways to keep customers' cargo moving
  • Maersk Cyber Attack: Will Ocean Freight Rates Increase ?
  • Maersk suffers a cyber attack causing IT systems to fail
  • Wan Hai Boosts China-Vietnam-Thailand Links
  • South Africa rejects Japanese container line merger proposal
  • ZIM must plot a course through some choppy financial waters
  • Fitch: Boxship Rates Rise, Capacity Still Key
  • Transpacific rates still under pressure but Asia-Europe space still tight
  • MSC prepares contingency plan for cargo aboard Rickmers charters
  • Imabari Launches 20,150 TEU MOL Boxship
  • Maersk Line Not Accepting Cargo to/from Qatari Ports
  • Hapag-Lloyd becomes latest carrier to bring in container booking cancellation fee
  • Middle East air freight disruption looms as Qatar is blacklisted over 'terror links'
  • Japanese liner shipping trio becomes ONE, ready for launch next spring
  • FMC Discusses Regulatory Reform Initiative and Ocean Carrier Alliances
  • China-Europe rail boom as forwarders latch on to cost advantage for customers
  • Hapag-Lloyd finally completes merger with UASC
  • APL turnaround brings significant boost to CMA CGM first-quarter results
  • Uber Freight officially parks in the marketplace, but only taking full loads
  • China Sparks World Container Traffic Boom
  • Navios Containers Eyes USD 75 Mn for Rickmers Fleet
  • Shippers squeezing margins 'pushed carriers toward bigger ships and alliances'
  • Crane Falls at Jebel Ali Port after Boxship Collision, No Fatalities
  • Nerves jangle as shippers and forwarders wait to hear who is bankrolling Yang Ming
  • Future Management of Hamburg Süd Unveiled
  • Shock for Japanese shipping lines as merger plan is rejected by US FMC
  • Yang Ming Expects 2nd Stage of Recapitalization by June
  • targets 3% growth as next-generation Triple-Es start to arrive
  • Sharp Decline in Idling Boxships
  • APL Enhances China-Indonesia Coverage
  • Yang Ming Halts Share Trading
  • Shanghai port, world's busiest, grapples with traffic congestion
  • Drewry: Bigger Ships to Continue Pressuring Freight Rates
  • Alibaba extends partnership with KN to cover cross-border B2B shipments
  • Seago Line Sees Modest Profit amid Lower Freight Rates
  • ZIM, MSC Upgrade North Europe Express Service
  • DHL Says Ocean Freight Rates Have Reached Turning Point
  • CMA CGM Strengthening EURAF 5 Services
  • OCEAN Alliance Starts Ploughing the Seas
  • Yang Ming losses continue to mount after 2016 revenue slump
  • FMC green light for 2M Alliance co-operation with HMM on transpacific
  • NYK, K Line and MOL pass first marker buoy en route to the merger